|
Editor's Introduction
Introduction
Organised research during the last decade has generated new
insights into the deep structure of the Indian continental
lithosphere, largely through a multi-institutional participation
and synthesis Of Multi-disciplinary data. The selected papers
in this volume provide a window on to the large benefits that
are accruing through these researches and the future directions
in which further work may be organized. The papers presented
here address several frontier ,areas of research and some
of the specific episodes in the long history of the evolution
of the Indian continent. They have been grouped under three
categories that will reflect the relative emphasis that is
being laid on researches on ft Deep Continental Studies. Six
papers present data from the recently completed transacts
and related studies; nine papers relate to regional studies
using both geological and geophysical methods and also a few
reviews of past achievements and four papers discuss different
aspects of the thermal structure. Included in this section
are also two papers on numerical modeling, a combination of
convenience.
Transects and Related Studies
The nineteen nineties may be called the decade of transacts,
when several transacts were selected and covered by multidisciplinary
approaches following the prescriptions of the International
Commission on Lithosphere. Several new transacts were completed
and include the Nagaur-Jhalawar (N-J) transect across the
Aravalli- Delhi Fold belt of Rajasthan; Miingwani-Seoni- Katangi-Kalimati
(MSKK) transect across Central Indian Shear Zone (CISZ) and
the Kuppam-Palani (K-P) transect cross the southern India
high-grade domain. An ongoing project translating the transect
concept is the HIMPROBE project that combines several scientific
traverses across the NW Himalaya, covering notably the area
between the Tso Morati Crystallines and the Karakorum Mountains.
The approach to these transacts have varied from terrain
to terrain especially with regard to the choice of methodology.
While the K-P transect combines coincident reflection-refraction
experiments with almost all available geophysical methodology,
reflection profiling has dominated over refraction experiments
in the other two profiles due largely to logistic reasons.
In the HIMPROBE project the terrain difficulties render seismic
profiling difficult and expensive. Extensive geological and
magneto-telluric and other potential under processing. Despite
these limitations, interesting models of evolution have emerged
from each of the transect programmes that can stimulate further
enquiry into the deep continental structure and continental
evolution.
HIMPROBE Project
The HIMPROBE project started in 1998 is still in a preliminary
stage of data collection and analysis. Interpreting the available
data, Jain et al. present tectonic evolutionary model, wherein
the open oceans in the region of the Karakoram Ranges had
a subduction-related island arc volcanic belt during the period
- 140-120 Ma. The ocean closed sequentially along the Karakoram
shear zone (KSZ) and the Shyok Shear Zone (SSZ).Me KSZ is
being proposed for the first time to define a distinct dextral
transpressional shear zone that juxtaposes the lithologies
of the SSZ against the frontal edge of the Eurasian plate.
Subsequent to the closure of the Tethyan Ocean by - 55 Ma,
intra- continental shortening of the mid- to upper crust imposed
a distinctive coesite- bearing ultra-high-pressure (UHP) mineralogy
on the eclogites and related petro-assemblages in the Tso
Morari crystallines belt, suggestive of continental subduction
to maximum depths of 60-100 km. The Tso-Morari complex was
possibly exhumed between 45-30 Ma. The orogenic impact seems
to have shifted thereafter to the Palaeo-Proterozoic Himalayan
Metamorphic belt (HMB) and its Tethyan cover leading to active
over thrusting along the Main Central Thrust and the Main
Boundary Thrust, spanning the period of 45 to 20 Ma. The thrust-
rnovements have continued into the forelands basin along the
MBT and the Indogangetic Plains thereafter. While continental
collision tectonics has coalesced the Himalaya and the Karakoram,
underthrusting of the Indian Plate still continues along the
Main Himalayan Thrust, contributing to seismogenesis.
MT studies have revealed a low-dipping 70 km wide conductive
zone beneath the Trans-Himalaya and the Karakoram at a shallow
depth of 15 km. This is believed to be a zone of partial melts.
Nagaur - Jhalawar (N-J) Transect
Tewari and Vijay Rao, present the results of seismic reflection
prof-lbng along the Nagaur-Jhalawar (N-J) transect across
the Aravalli- Delhi Fold belt Rajasthan. The profile offers
Only limited velocity data but a gross velocity model has
been still possible by dynamic forward modeling using ray
method and by synthesis with gravity data. The crustal structure
below the transect is complex. A thickened (48 km) crust is
dissected by deep penetrating faults and ffimsts, some extending
down to Moho depths. The reflective pattern shows diversity
correlatable with the different tectonics settings. Changes
in the character of reflectivity demarcate tectonic boundaries.
A prominent feature is a dome structure above the Moho under
the relatively younger Delhi fold belt and the Sandmata granulite
complex fringing it. The dome structure defines a zone of
7.3 knvsec P-wave velocity. Synthesising the seismic data
with gravity and electrical conductivity data, the authors
present an evolutionary sequence centering around a plate
tectonic regime in the Palaeo- and Meso-proterozoic involving
rifting opening and closing of oceans between the Bundelkhand
block on the east and the Mewar block on the west.
Mungwani-Seoni-Katangi-Kalimati (MSKK)
Transect
Reddy and Rao present a review of the coincident reflection-refraction
experiments carried out along the NW-SE trending Mungwani-Seoni-Katangi-
Kalimati (MS KK) profile across Central Indian Shear Zone
(CISZ) and integrate the results with 5 DSS profiles prepared
across the Narmada-Son Lineament earlier. 7he MSKK profile
reveals a distinct change in the reflectivity of the crust
across the CISZ and a convergence of dips of the reflectors
on either side. The line of convergence nearly coincides with
the CISZ along which the Amgaon Gneisses in the south are
thrust up against the Sausar-Tirodi gneisses with some granulite
bands (charnockites). A 5-layer velocity structure is proposed
along the transect within a thickened crust, 44-46 km thick,
which includes two low velocity layers, Reddy and Rao propose
a collision model to explain the convergence. Synthesizing
the MSKK profile data with the data from earlier DSS profiles
across the Narmada-Son Lineament, it is suggested that several
of the features may be viewed as resulting from the impact
of the Reunion hot spot on the western margins of the Indian
shield.
South Indian Transect
The more significant results accruing from this project have
already been published. (Ramakri shnan, M. (Ed.), Memoir 50,
Geol. Soc. India., 2003). A review of these and related results
and their bearing on the geological evolution of the Southern
Indian shield in the Archaean through the Proterozoic is presented
by Mahadevan. The high grade- domain of the Peninsular Shield
has many major unique features that include a four-layered
velocity-density structure above the Moho with a rnid- to
lower crustal low velocity layer with distinctive electrical
conductivity and magnetic attributes; a distinctive pattern
of both dipping and in places domical high reflectivity and
a distinctive thermal structure. It is suggested that the
characteristic reflective crust and the low velocity layer
may be features developed during the differential exhumation
of the lower crust through a dominantly isothermal decompression
path and the several punctuated episodes of ultrabasic, basic,
alkaline and granitic magmatism in the span of-2500 to 550
Ma. The deep crustal structure deciphered is consistent with
a geological history of extensive fluid-mobilisation and numerous
mantle-related magmatic episodes of the Proterozoic. Mahadevan
links the diachronous evolution of the Archaean Dharwar craton
and the Archaean-Proterozoic HGD to the coffesponding diachronous
change in both the thermal structure and chemistry of the
mantle from the Archaean to the Proterozoic.
Teleseismic Receiver Function
Studies on teleseisniie receiver funcfion carried out in India
since recently constitute a new dimension to deep continental
Studies. Prakasam and Rai outline results of such studies
in modeling the crustal structure below the Eastern Dharwar
Craton.(EDC) based on recordings in a network of broadband
stations in the EDC and the fringing Deccan Volcanic Province.Mey
model a relatively homogeneous crust across the EDC and the
DVP with a sharp Moho at variable depths. The crust is 31-36
km thick and the Poisson's ratio ranges 0.24-0.27. The upper
crust is up to 12 km thick and the Lower Crust isfelsic to
intermediate in composition.
Electrical Conductivity Traverses
The last decade witnessed new developments in the methodology
of electromagnetic investigations and its extensive application.
A significant finding has been the presence of n-iid-crustal
conductors in the dominantly Precambrian Peninsular shield.
While the causative factors of the conductivity may be debated,
correlation with low velocity zones bestows on these zones
both a tectonic (Theological) and petrological significance.
Possibilities of fluid enriched zones within an otherwise
brittle crust lend to these discov -eries of seismogenic significance.
In his contribuion Gokarn of TIG compares the electrical structure
below a transect across the south Indian Dharwar craion; across
the central Indian region and the NW Himalaya. Interestingly,
in all the three regions of distinctive but younging temporal
evolution, a refractory crust is underlain by a more conductive
lower crust. While no electrical Moho is evident in any of
the profiles, presumably because of a conductive lower crust,
these findings point to a fluid-enriched lower crust in all
the three regions transacted.
Exhumation of Deep Domains
A major characteristic of the Indian shield are the extensive
dominantly Proterozoic domains of high-grade rocks that seem
to encircle a central core of Archaean-early Proterozoic greenstone-granite
belts. Researches during the last two decades have addressed
the question of the styles of exhumation of these bigh-grade
domains and a prominent approach has been to trace their P-T-t
paths of evolution through mainly petro-mineralogy. In the
first paper Anand Mohan traces the evolutionary history in
terms of the P-T-t paths of the high- grade rocks of south
India using refined calibrations of mineral equilibria and
thermodynamic bases. It is inferred that near thermal peak
of granulite facies metamorphism at >900"C at 9 kb
pressure were followed by isothermal decompressional path
These results support several earlier findings and provide
a sharper definition to the style and manner of exhumation
of the high grade domain of southern India
Phanerozoic Rifting and Voicanism
The Rajamahal and Deccan Volcanic episodes have been the two
great events during the Phanerozoic that have had a major
impact on the deep continental structure of the Indian shield.
Ghose and Ray Kent present a review of the field, petrochemical
and geochronological aspects of the Rajmahal flows in the
type area of Rajmahal Volcanism. These flows are largely tholeiites
grading rather locally into basaltic andesite and more acid
fields. 'Mey are chemically distinct from those of Deccan
Basalts, implying a distinct mantle source. They are divided
into two chemical groups, the early phases of eruption being
enriched in transition elements (Fe, Ni, Cr, V and Sc), TiO.
and CaO and Ti/Zr and e Nd(t) and relatively depleted in incompatible
elements. The second types have strong differentiation patterns
with negative Nb and Ta anomalies, and positive Rb, Ba, K,
Th, Zr and Hf. REE chemistry reveals lesser fractionation
in the former. The authors infer that the two groups have
evolved through variable but low degrees of cnistal contamination
of mantle -derived magmas followed by fractional crystallisation
ol'the contaminated iiiagilia ill the upper crust. Hf and
Ar/Ar isotope systematics date the Rajmahal events - 1 15
Ma. The authors infer that the Kerguelen hotspot was close
to the Eastern Indian margin around this time. The data that
have accrued through these researches have the potential to
model the chemical evolution of the mantle source areas through
time.
The Deccan voicanism is One of the most intensively investigated
volcanic suites. Chandrasekharam presents the status of our
present knowledge on the Deccan continental basaits and identifies
the gaps in our understanding. The paper focuses on the diversity
of views with regard to the extent, age and duration of the
Deccan volcanism, the chemical stratigraphy, crustal contamination,
the tectonic and plume settings associated with the vocalism
and eruptive models. Deccan Volcanism being one of the largest
of continental basalt eruptions in the world, a resolution
of several divergent views on almost every aspect of this
great phenomenon is fundamental to get a clear insight into
the evolution the earths's crust in the latter part of the
Phanerozoic.
Mantle Xenoliths
Xenoliths of both 10wez'crustal and mantle rocks entrained
in magmas generated in the mantle by partial melting are,
the only real messengers of the source areas Of these magmas
and have the potential to throw light on the composition of
their source depths. Integration of their petrology and chemistry
with several geophysical signals, such as gravity., seismic
velocity structure, electrical conductivity and so on can
greatly constrain the models of the deep continental structure.
A ]inciting factor is that the incidence of mantle xenoliths
in mantle-derived magmatic intrusives in India seems to be
low and confined to a few areas. Nevertheless a beginning
has been made in integrated studies on the known xenoliths.
From among these are a suite of xenoliths of pyroxenites,
websterites, rare wehrlite and pyroxene granulites occurring
in alkaline dyke swarms of Janjira- Munid areas south of Mumbai
and the spinel Iherzolite xenoliths occurring in the early
alkaline basaits of Kutch. These are related respectively
to the late and early phases of Deccan voicailism of late
Cretaceous-Palaeocene ages. Dessai in Ns contribution discusses
the inferred P-'T' conditions of the source mantle/lower crust
sites of the xenoliths. A synthesis with the known seismic
profiles across these regions confirms a 3-layer velocity
model of the crust beneath the craton. He further concludes
that the exhumed lower crust beneath the attenuated margin
of the continent is largely dominated by mafic granulites
interstratified with pyroxenites and websterites. A transitional
Moho is suspected in these regions of peri-continental late
Mesozoic rifting.
Interpretation of Magnetic Fields
The largevolulyle of the magnetic data thlt flow from satellite
and aerial platforms and ground surveys provides unprecedented
opportunities for applying magnetic methods to earth science
research in general and deep continental studies in particular.
The data from these three sources are characterized by a range
of wavelengths and have distinctiveness in application to
modeling source depths contributing to the respective fields
measured. Addressing these sources Ntta Rajaram reviews some
of the outstanding achievements in interpreting magnetic data
in relation to the Indian subcontinent. A notable development
is the use of the analytical signal map, in wtuch the maxima
mark the edges of the magnetic bodies, thereby bringing out
the presence of larger magnetic sources and filtered maps
in which one can remove, minimize or enhance relevant source
components and source depths. Comparison of aeromagnetic data
with digitized gravity data, using high-pass filtering techniques
helps to interpret distinctive source depths. Estimating the
,average spectral depths from power spectra plots of the filtered
aeromagnetic anomaly for wavelengths of <80km, I 00 Ian,
180km and 2OOkm, it is established that the Dharwar cratonic
region of largely Archaean age has distinctive magnetic fields
compared to the high-grade domain. Significantly the high-
grade domain has a thin magnetic crust, the crust below -
22 km not contributing to the magnetic anomalies. This may
be due to any of two reasons (i) compositional changes below
22 kms or alternatively due to the magnetization having been
lost due to Curie isotherm. The findings are consistent with-a
low velocity layer below - 24 km in the velocity structure
of the region, generated through a coincident reflection-refraction
experiment recently completed along the Kuppam- Palrii transect.
Palaeomagnetic Insights
From its early application to palaeocontinental reconstruction,
palaeomagnatic research has expanded into several applied
areas such as providing temporal constraints on stratigraphy,
sedimentation and evolution of basins, dating magmatism and
dating palaeo-environmental changes. Radhakrishna presents
a review of the status of the pal aeomagnetic researches in
India since its inception. The available palaeomagnetic data
are evaluated by basic reliability criteria. Several new directions
for future research are suggested.
Constraints on Hinialayan Seisniicity
One of the major objectives of the Deep Continental Studies
programme is to constrain seismicity through well-defined
deep structure and reliable velocity models. This is a challenging
task but some insights haN7e been gained on crustal constraints
on stress accumulations through teleseismic studies, micro-earhquake
(MF-Q) studies, monitoring after-shocks; and electrical conductivity
studies. In his contribution, Kayal outlines some of the insights
gained regarding the seismotectonics in the Himalaya on the
basis of micro- earthquake studies. The seismotectonic models
generated differ from west to east Himalaya and the NE Himalaya.
In the NE Himalaya earthquakes are generated much below the
plane of detachment of the currently accepted steady state
model and are caused by the influence of the Himalayan collision
tectonics in the north and the Bunnese arc subduction in the
east. The earthquakes in the Shillong Plateau are generated
by locally active reverse faults. In the east Himalaya, in
Sikkim and the Darjeeling, seismic activity is generated at
depths of 0 to 50 km below the trace of the MBT. In the North
Himalaya (Fhmachal Pradesh) hypocenters are confined above
the plane of detachment, as exemplified by the recent 1991
Uttarkashi earthquake of 6.6 Mb and the 1999 Chamoli earthquake
of K6.3). 'Me MCT is not active in any of the arm. Shocks
are generated by thrust faulting in the Basement Thrust Front.
'Me tectonic models, therefore, are distinctive in each of
the tectonic provinces.
Indian lithosphere : Some Issues related
to Evolution
Avasthi discusses several problems related to the evolution
of the Indian lithosphere, with special reference to the litho-tectonic
boundaries within the Indian plate,-the Himalayan front in
the north and the oceanic front in the eastern, western and
southern boundaries. Within the continental segment of specific
importance is the deciphering of the characteristic relationship
between the seismic velocity profile, density profile and
the thermal conductivity profile. A major issue to be clarified
in the off-shore and oceanic parts is the constitution of
several of the oceanic ridges, whether they are continental
or oceanic in character. these emphasize the need to extend
deep continental studies into the Greater Indian plate as
a whole and not merely to the continental land mass.
THERMAL STRUCTURE AND NUMERICAL MODELING
Thermal Structure
Systematic heat now studies in India date back to the past
five decades, but have been based on logging of boreholes
drilled for mineral exploration and groundwater. For the first
time heat flow estimates were refined by using the down-the-hole-hammer
(DT14) non-coring holes to depths of 300-600ni in some 12
select spots in the Southern Indian granulite terrain. The
sites were selected on the basis of homogeneity of formations,
low depths of weathering and low groundwater potential so
that a more or less stabilised heat flow can be measured.
Heat generation measurements, hither-to-fore, were based on
radio-nucleiide estimates in the laboratory on single specimens.
But these were carried out in situ on carefully selected flat
outcrops in the field using a 4 channel gamma-ray spectrometer.
The method permits enlarging sample size to some 40 kg in
contrast to less < 1 kg in laboratory samples.
Rao et al. review the overall data that have accrued on the
geothermal gradients in different crustal segments of the
Peninsular Shield through measurements in some 183 boreholes
and two deep mines. The heat flow characteristics in the dominantly
Archaean Dharwar and Bastar cratonic regions as,,also the
Proterozoic Aravalli-Delhi fold belt in NW part of the Shield
and the Singhbhum Shear Zone in Eastern India show a wide
but overlapping range of 25 to 62 mWm-1; the coldest is the
western Dharwar craton. The Mesozoic Gondwana basins and the
late Mesozoic-Cenozoic Cambay rift zones have overlapping
heat flow ranges of 46-107 m W m-2.
Estimates of crustal heat generation viewed against the total
heat flow lead to a robust estimate of 12 to 19 mWm-2 in the
Dharwar province but 25-30 mWm-2 in the northern part of the
Southern Granulite Province. This is consistent with an enriched
mantle that may exist below the Southern Granulite terrain,
inferred through researches in geochemistry of some of the
plutonites in the region.
Heat flow measurements of 43 mWm-2 in a bore hole drilled
at the site of the 6.2 M Killari- 1993 earthquake point to
a brittle crust up to some 30 km depth. The centroid depth
of the Killari event estimated at 2.6 km tilts the causative
factor to increase of fluid pore pressure over hydrostatic
pressure.
Electrical Conductivity Studies across
Northern Indian Ocean
A new. significant trend in recent researches is the extension
of electrical conductivity studies to constrain models of
the plume lithosphere interactions in the Indian Ocean. Arora
et al. present results of recent researches in this direction.
Transient geomagnetic field variations recorded at a number
of sites distributed across the Peninsular Shield and in the
Arabian Sea, interpreted through a thin sheet conductance
model, lends definition to the source region of high conductivity
in the offshore region SW of the southern tip of the Indian
Peninsula. The anomaly is named the South India Offshore Conductive
anomaly" (SIOCA). This anomaly coincides with the low
velocity zone and low magnetisation anomaly centered near
the southern tip of the Indian shield. Arora et al. interpret
these anomalies as the manifestation of the impact of the
Marion Plume on the Indian Shield. The poorly constrained
weak induction features below the 850 E Ridge may point to
localized magmatic intrusions and the relatively pronounced
induction anomalies at stations flanking the Ridge may be
due to sources of sediment filled troughs, on either side
of the Ridge.
Fluid Dynamics of the Mantle
An important dimension of deep continental study is mathematical
modeling taking into consideration several boundary conditions.
Manglik outlines the basic principles of mathematical modeling
of fluid dynamics of the mantle, taking into consideration
current concepts of the modes of mantle convection influenced
by the presence of subducting slabs, lithosphere-mantle interaction
with particular reference to decompression melting of the
mantle, the effects of continents on the mantle flow pattern
and plume- lithosphere interaction in a rifted lithosphere
and below lithospheric roots He then proceeds to address questions
regarding core-mantle interaction.
Scaling Spectral Analysis
Several physical properties of rocks such as density, magnetic
susceptibility and reflectivity follow a scaling distribution.
Dimri et al. demonstrate the effective application of the
scaling spectral method through the interpretation of the
gravity profiles along the Nagaur- Jhalawar and Jaipur- Raipur
seismic transacts The results of scaling are in good agreement
with the observed features in the seismic profiles. The efficacy
of the method is proposed to be verified using gravity and
magnetic measurements in the vicinity of a bore well of the
ONGC in the Jabera-Damoh area in the Vindhyan Basin.
Mantle Plumes and Continental Evolution
Interaction between mantle plumes and continental lithosphere
is recognized as a major paradigm that can explain many lithospheric
features imbibed from Archaean times through the Phanerozoic.
i'lava't discusses the impact of mantle plumes on the Indian
plate since the Cretaceous and proposes that plume and plate
tectonics have played complimentary roles, but of one predominating
over the other through time and space. He emphasizes the larger
influence of plumes along the earlier mobile belts generated
by plate tectonics as against regimes that have been already
cratonised.
Future Thrust
Each of the papers in the volume provides suggestions for
future researches in the specific areas addressed that could
be incorporated in the frame work of a national programme
of research on the deep structure of the Indian continental
lithosphere. The broad approach in this regard should be to
integrate the large data-base that has been created with the
even larger data- base already available, especially with
regard to the potential fields, including the satellite and
aeromagnetic data and the data from the numerous controlled
seismology experiments, teleseisniic and electrical conductivity
studies. The new data presented in and exemplified by the
papers in this volume have a great potential for further processing
and refinement and even re-interpretations in the light of
new models that may be proposed for continental evolution
in the future.
A significant new source of data is the network of seismic
stations that have been now established with state-of-art
equipments. The large amount of seismic data flowing from
these stations can revolutionise our efforts to gain insights
into the deep continental structure of the Indian continent.
A direction of seismological research that remains neglected
is the shear wave velocity structure. Seismic Tomography needs
to be extended on a larger scale over the continent and the
adjoining off-shore extensions. The Himalaya needs special
attention with regard to generating a reliable velocity structure
along and across so that current models of seismicity could
be verified and a more realistic data base generated that
can constrain earthquake studies. Electrical conductivity
studies need to be enhanced on a larger scale and preparation
of an electrical conductance map of India should be a long
term objective. A related problem that needs to be addressed
is the thermal structure both below, the Shield as well as
the Himalaya. The dynamic nature of Himalaya calls for addressing
this problem through innovative approaches.
While geochemical researches have been addressing some of
the problems i-elating to lithosphere-mantle interactions
and are integrated with geochronotogy, most modeling is based
on assumptions of uniformitarianism. An alternative emerging
approach is to relate geocheiwstrv of the crust with the chemical
evolution of the mantle. This calls for carefully planned
programmes on the one hand and larger facilities for especially
isotope studies, as for example using Re-Os systematics. DST
has already initiated steps in iffis direction and it is hoped
that geochemical researches would register greater heights
of progress.
This note may be concluded by recalling the three-pronged
conceptual approach to deep continental studies that has been
the driving force behind the whole programme of researches
initiated by the DST in the past.
1 . Understanding continental evolution through the fourth
dimension of "TIME".
2. Gaining insights into the geodynamics and seismic instability
of regions thereby enabling better management of seismic environment
and preparing for a more distant objective of seismic prediction
and
3. Generation of new and more realistic concepts of the formation
of mineral deposits and metallogenic provinces by addressing
crust- mantle domains of geochernical interaction through
time.
It is hoped that the next few decades would achieve substantial
progress in these directions.
T.M. MAHADEVAN, B.R. ARORA and
K.R. GUPTA
|